Objection 18 of 19

The Bible endorses slavery.

Strongest form (steelman)

Exodus 21 regulates how hard you can beat your slave (as long as they survive a day or two, no punishment). Leviticus 25:44-46 explicitly permits buying foreign slaves as inheritable property. Paul returns the runaway Onesimus to his master. No text in the Bible says "abolish slavery." For 1,800 years American and European Christians owned human beings and quoted scripture to justify it. If the Bible's morality needed 19th-century secular reformers to correct it, it cannot be the timeless word of a just God.

Response

Three layers: (1) The text itself, carefully read; (2) the trajectory it sets; (3) the history of actual abolition. (1) OT "slavery" (ʿebed) was predominantly indentured servitude as debt-relief, time-bounded (Ex 21: release in seven years), with legal protections unheard of in the ancient world: fugitive slave laws running in favor of the slave (Deut 23:15-16 - uniquely in the ANE), the death penalty for kidnapping (Ex 21:16 - which outlaws the entire trans-Atlantic slave trade at the source), sabbath rest for servants (Ex 20:10), and freedom for any maimed in beatings (Ex 21:26-27). This is not a permissive slave code; it is a severely constrained one compared to Babylonian, Roman, or Greek systems. (2) The NT trajectory: Paul tells slaveowners "Masters, treat your slaves justly and fairly, knowing that you also have a Master in heaven" (Col 4:1), calls Onesimus a "beloved brother...both in the flesh and in the Lord" (Philemon 16), and insists on "no slave nor free" before God (Gal 3:28). The seeds of abolition are planted here, explicitly. (3) Historical effect: the first large-scale abolition movements in human history - in the late Roman empire under Christian emperors, in medieval Europe, and decisively in Britain (Wilberforce, Clapham sect) and the U.S. (Quakers, Wesleyans, evangelical Second Great Awakening) - were driven by Christians appealing to the Bible, against the resistance of nominal Christians who defended slavery. Historian David Brion Davis (Inhuman Bondage) and Rodney Stark (For the Glory of God) document this. Abolition did not come from Enlightenment rationalists in general (many of whom, like Jefferson, owned slaves); it came from Bible-quoting evangelicals. (4) The Bible could have included a sentence saying "own no humans" - but it would have been read as authorizing rebellion in a society where slavery was economically structural. Instead it plants principles - the imago Dei, redemption-from-slavery as the constitutive Israelite memory, the master-servant reversal of the cross - that detonated the institution wherever they were actually applied.

Follow-up

The shameful record of Christian complicity in New World slavery is real, and the biblical case against it was available the whole time. The better question is: which worldview actually produced the end of slavery? The honest historical answer is uncomfortable for the objector.

Sources & citations

Sources
  • Unimaginable: What Our World Would Be Like Without Christianity — Jeremiah J. Johnston (2017)popularFind on Amazon
  • Is God a Moral Monster? Making Sense of the Old Testament God — Paul Copan (2011)scholarlyFind on Amazon